What Happened in Agua Fria

A gunslinger walks into a saloon and yells…

“…which one of you lily-livered, yellow-bellied, flea-bitten curs stole my horse!?”

The room is silent.

The gunslinger continues. “Alright! Here’s what’s going to happen! I’m going to buy a beer, drink it, and then I’m going back outside! And if my horse isn’t there, I’m going to have to do here what I did in Agua Fria! I don’t want to, but if I don’t get my horse back… you aren’t really giving me much of a choice!”

The gunslinger gets his beer, drinks it, and walks outside, only to find his horse at the watering trough. As he gets into the saddle, the bartender comes out and nervously asks: “So… what did you do in Agua Fria?”

“Walked out of town and never went back.”

Heckle this joke

Got a better punchline or a worse take? Drop a one-liner.

Nobody has heckled this yet. Suspicious restraint.

Optional. Bad aliases encouraged.

0/280 · Moderated before publishing.

I’m really pissed off. I picked up a guy from Craigslist, got

I’m really pissed off. I picked up a guy from Craigslist, got off, and dropped him at the bus stop after giving him $2 — and he never gave me back my change!

Posted: May 13, 2026 (4 months ago)
Views: 0
Shares: 0
Topics: irony, misunderstanding, western
Sensitivity: Clean